Spread of fraudulent DMCA deletion notifications Destiny 2 content On YouTube earlier this year $ 7.6 million proceedings, Like a bungee chasing a suspect in court.Also, some Destiny 2 Content creators now feel “betrayed” after a person who appears to be responsible denies this during a private Discord chat with them. “I feel lied, betrayed, and incredibly upset that someone we know and trust will do this,” he wrote. Fate Twitter music remixer Owen Spence. “Literally, almost all of YouTube’s Destiny music is gone because of this.”
Unpacking is hard and starts with lots of YouTube videos. Including some of the bungee himselfWas hit by a DMCA removal notice in March of this year. Bungie announced that the notice was fraudulent and, a few weeks later, brought the issue to court to have Google disclose the identity of the person responsible. As Bungie pointed out at the time, one of the reasons Bungie was able to escalate fraudulent deletion notifications first was because YouTube’s copyright system was opaque and difficult to navigate (Bungie used customer service, but the problem. Was not resolved. Everyday). A few months later, the studio is now Destiny 2 Based on personal data obtained from Google on June 10th, a player named Nickminer by Sir Nazo on YouTube is allegedly responsible.
Miner and Bungy did not immediately respond to the request for comment.
“This proceeding is part of Bungie’s most prominent and passionate member of the fan base on behalf of Bungie in clear retaliation for Bungie’s exercise of copyright on material uploaded to his YouTube channel. It stems from Nick Minor’s malicious campaign to provide fraudulent removal notices to YouTube, “the company wrote in a new proceeding filed in Washington’s Western District Court on June 22.
Bungee claims that the miners ripped the music Destiny: The Taken King When Destiny 2: Witch Queen I uploaded it to YouTube directly from the company’s official soundtrack. Despite repeated deletion notices, the miner left the music and eventually YouTube completely disabled the miner’s channel. According to Bungie, miners began to impersonate third-party agencies when they used a copyright protection called CSC Global to enforce copyright protection using a fake Gmail address similar to that of the company.
Minors are alleged to have illegally deleted 96 other videos in retaliation for the deletion of their channel. Fate YouTube music scene. Bungy also used a smoke screen suspected that Minor was caused by his takedown banquet, Fate Counterclaim the legitimate removal notice to the community and his channel.
“I was very disappointed to find out that Sir Nazo, our friend and in direct contact with us about the takedown, was the one who issued the fake DMCA takedown on behalf of the bungee.” Says Owen Spence, the orchestrator. Remix Destiny 2 music, I have written On Twitter yesterday. “”[Minor] He lied to us, started Discord Group DM with me, Promethean, Breshi, Lorcan0c, and then said something like this, acting as if he were a victim. “
The Called the Discord chat log In March, the miner explains how easy it is to send a rogue deletion notice, suggesting that the perpetrator is someone who is abusing the YouTube system. A Screen grab of old tweetsIn the meantime, it looks like it shows a minor write Destiny 2The community manager was about the same time he was accidentally involved in the deletion, even though his channel was allegedly behind it. During this time, he also posted a manifest criticizing YouTube’s copyright removal policy.
As the bungee lays out in that case, Destiny 2 Is a live service game that is partially thriving as a result of the player community on other social platforms such as Twitch, YouTube, Twitter and Reddit. One area of community content is music such as loop tracks, remixes, re-orchestration, and fan covers. Spence does what the miners did (uploading a direct official soundtrack ripping and then looping through a small audio edit), an in-game recording-based save attempt, and a more innovative piece. Contrast (although it’s unclear if Bungie agrees with this distinction). However, as a result of the apparent behavior of the miners, many of the latter groups have also disappeared from YouTube.
As an example, YouTube channel Promethean, Archive Mind, uploaded music to be played in-game. Some of them still exist, First disciple raid boss battleMany others were removed during the deletion, to avoid losing the entire channel. There is an offline backup, but Promethean wrote in a March update on YouTube that it will get pre-approval directly from Bungie before proceeding with future projects.On Twitter yesterday, they simply I have written“Well … there’s a twist I didn’t see coming …”
“”[Minor’s] The decision was a terrible attempt to draw attention to the problems that ultimately resulted in the destruction of what he was concerned about, “Promethane said. Kotaku With DM on Twitter. They also said there is still an “ongoing dialogue” with Bungie on what kind of Destiny music can be uploaded to YouTube in the future.
Bungy does not downplay the alleged crime. The studio is seeking “damages and injunctive relief” for alleged financial and reputational harm resulting from the incident. These damages include “$ 150,000 for each work related to fraudulent deletion notices”, for a total of $ 7,650,000 plus statutory costs.Just last week, Bungy won twice that reconciliation. Dispute with Destiny 2 Cheet cellar.. On the other hand, minor YouTube channels have less than 3,000 subscribers.
Update: 6/23/22, 2:15 pm ET: Bungee admits in the proceedings Weekly blog post updates upon Destiny 2 He said he is working on a license request for uploading archived music. The complete statement is:
of Previous TWABLet everyone know that a series of copyright removal issues on YouTube have been identified as fraudulent by someone impersonating our intellectual property protection service. We wanted to provide a brief up-to-date with all affected people to identify the person responsible and to inform them that they are taking legal action.
We take these issues seriously and invest the time and resources needed to protect our community from malicious attackers.
That said Do not harass, attack, or stack up this individual.. Direct efforts outside of Bungy’s legal team can undermine our priority, our ability to deal with the harm done to our community. We have your backing on this and ensure that this individual meets the future they deserve. We are grateful for that feeling, but we are not asking for your help to make it happen.
Having identified this person, we have resolved some of the challenges we faced when reviewing license requests for uploading archived music. If you have been waiting for these, please wait for a while. We will get back to you within a few weeks.